Jump to content
Stephen

Scenery Review : TNCM - Princess of the Caribbean - Part 1- SXM by AWD

Recommended Posts

TNCM - Header.jpg

 

Scenery Review : TNCM - Princess of the Caribbean - Part 1- SXM by AWD

 

In either tourism or aviation it is one of the most famous images known...  the image of a KLM Boeing 747 passing over Beacon Hill Road (Maho Beach) on finals and about to land at Princess Juliana International Airport (PJIA) in Sint Maarten.

 

TNCM - Head 1.jpgTNCM - Head 2.jpg

 

It is now history as well as KLM don't fly Boeing 747's to Sint Maarten any more since they started in 1990, as the final flight was held on 28 October 2016. The aircraft would generally fly from Amsterdam, making a stop in Curacao before heading to St. Maarten. But however you can still fly on the route (but only direct AMS - SXM) and now on an Airbus A330 (FL KL789).

 

Besides trying to duplicate that image in X-Plane (it is far harder than it looks) Sint Maarten is a great base to explore the Anguilla area and islands, this is island hopping par excellence and X-Plane has had a variety of TNCM airports over the years but not one to do the area real justice, so here is Airworthy Design's version and it is a big if huge scenery of the area.

 

I will note is that "is this now the era of Mega Sceneries" for X-Plane, it feels like it, as scenery is now expanding, not only in cost but certainly in size. But the size aspect isn't in area, but in actual scenery size...  in Gigabytes. This scenery is a total of 14.71GB...  yes that is 14.7 big ones! with a 6.5gb download. The recommended requirement is 4Gb VRAM Video Card Minimum and a 8Gb+ VRAM recommended in graphic cards but you will need at least 16gb of memory as well. An update reduced the download to 5.5GB, but the file size is the same. So the scenery is asking a lot of your specifics, and even I with my review Windows setup, the size just only crawls under that line. I will note my graphic settings here as they are important to the running of this scenery (as to all these newer mega sceneries) they are High (HDR), Maximum (Texture Quality), Highest Quality (AntiAliasing), High (Objects), Minimal (Reflection).

 

The scenery is also part 1 of two editions of the area, this scenery covers the main entrance to the area with Princess Juliana (TNCM) and Grand Case airports (TFFG) and photo scenery over the island of Anguilla. The second edition will cover St Barths (TFFJ) and Saba (TNCS). But the Clayton J. Lloyd International Airport on Anguilla will not be covered, which is an odd omission?

 

To clear up a slight confusion is the names of Sint Maarten and Saint Martin, the island is split between the Dutch (Sint) 40% and the French - Collectivité de Saint-Martin (Saint) of which is the Northern 60%.and the Princess Juliana airport is just south of the border in the Dutch zone and is Dutch in operation, for the French national interests it is the Aéroport de Grand Case or L'Espérance Airport (TFFG) that is positioned in the north of the island.

 

You get a good idea of the large area provided with the scenery by turning off all of X-Plane's weather features...  and see the layout of Sint Maarten.

 

TNCM - Head 3.jpgTNCM - Head 4.jpg

 

I have always noted that X-Plane has required an good Sint Maarten for years, yes as noted there has been a few, but the trick with this island scenery is not with the actual airport itself, but the overall surroundings and the overall feel of the Anguilla islands...

 

TNCM - Overview 1.jpgTNCM - Overview 2.jpg

TNCM - Overview 3.jpgTNCM - Overview 4.jpg

 

...  and the trick of course is the water, or the colouring of the aspects of the water to note the islands tropical look and feel.

 

TNCM - Princess Juliana International Airport

The airport was started as a military airstrip in 1942. It was converted to a civilian airport in 1943. In 1964 the airport was remodeled and relocated, with a new terminal building and control tower. The facilities were upgraded in both 1985 and 2001 and the airport airport handles around 1,829,543 passengers and around 60,000 aircraft movements per year.

 

Noted is that TNCM is famous as the 4th most dangerous airport in the world because the approach to Runway 10 which is over water and pilots can become easily disoriented regarding their perceived altitude when operating under visual flight rules. Normal instrument checks, coupled with experience and situational awareness, mitigate potential problems. The departure from Runway 10 presents more "difficulties" than the approach, with a turn required to avoid mountains in the departure path.

 

Arriving aircraft approach the island on the last section of the final approach for Runway 10, following a 3° glide slope flying low over the famous Maho Beach. Pictures of low-flying aircraft were published in several news magazines worldwide in early 2000. The thrilling approaches and ease of access for shooting spectacular images, made the airport one of the world's favorite places among planespotters and of course simulator users in wanting to recapture the challenging approaches and departures.

 

This scenery covers the latest upgrades to the airport (since damaged badly by Hurricane Irma on the 6 September 2017 which struck the island as a Category 5 hurricane).

 

Princess Juliana
International Airport

IATA: SXM - ICAO: TNCM

 

TNCM - Overview 5.jpgTNCM - Overview 6.jpg

TNCM - Overview 7.jpgTNCM - Overview 8.jpg

 

10/28 - 2,300m (7,546ft) Asphalt/Concrete

Elevation AMSL14ft / 4m

 

TNCM - Airport 1.jpgTNCM - Airport 3.jpg

 

In reality TNCM can be set into two zones, the main area with the single large international terminal building (top) and the inter-island area for the mostly twin-engined island hoppers (below).

 

TNCM - Airport 4.jpgTNCM - Airport 2.jpg

 

Note the very large radar installation here at TNCM. As since the official opening of the new control tower, PJIA air traffic controllers have two radar systems now at their disposal with ranges of 50 nautical miles (93 km) and 250 nautical miles (460 km). PJIA controllers manage 4,000 square NM of airspace known as the Juliana TCA around the airport, roughly between 25 nautical miles (46 km) and 42 nautical miles (78 km) of the St Maarten VOR-DME. Besides providing approach, tower and ground control at PJIA, these controllers also provide airport approach control for Clayton J. Lloyd International Airport (Anguilla), L'Espérance Airport (French Saint Martin), Gustaf III Airport (St. Barths), F.D. Roosevelt Airport (St. Eustatius) and Juancho E. Yrausquin Airport (Saba).

 

The terminal's design and textures are first-rate, with great graphic design to highlight the island destination. It is a big building and very striking in construction, The Terminal has four air-gates (A1 - A4), but they are not active DGS gates and excellent reflective (see-through) glass.

 

TNCM - Terminal 1.jpgTNCM - Terminal 2.jpgTNCM - Terminal 3.jpgTNCM - Terminal 4.jpgTNCM - Terminal 5.jpg

 

All the interior check-in and departure areas are modeled with not only the usual chairs and shops, but people as well, and you can actually see out of the windows of the parked aircraft.

 

TNCM - Terminal 6.jpgTNCM - Terminal 7.jpgTNCM - Terminal 8.jpgTNCM - Terminal 9.jpg

 

There is a huge amount of everything available in this scenery...  static aircraft, tons of ground support equipment, cars, buses and almost every item to convey an island lifestyle you could dream of...

 

TNCM - Airport 5.jpgTNCM - Airport 6.jpgTNCM - Airport 7.jpgTNCM - Airport 8.jpgTNCM - Airport 9.jpgTNCM - Airport 10.jpg

 

It is very extensive and in fact in a few areas a bit overcompensated with a bit of editing that could still convey the same thing, but with less clutter...  like why are there private jet aircraft in the Cargo area and why some signs are reversed and how many Fire Trucks does an Airport need?

 

TNCM - Airport 11.jpgTNCM - Airport 12.jpg

 

The Inter-Island area is very well done with hangars and aircraft, but again it is crowded and you will have to find a parking stand on the main apron, as this area is again full to capacity. Some users have noted floating objects around the terminal (mostly the airbridges) but in checking my installation it is fine.

 

All AutoGate and GroundTraffic as well as Maritime Traffic and AI Aircraft is not yet included and that also means "traffic". You can use the older WT3 ground routes for TNCM, but they are not tuned for this scenery, so aircraft are spread around in the wrong parking areas and clash with the terminal...

 

TNCM - Airport 13.jpg

 

Tower View

The tower view here is well...  different. The idea is to give you view as the controller, but it doesn't work. You are too far back from the actual point of view of where the control would actually stand and so the tower's broken framework intrudes into the view and the point of tower view is to give you a clear view of the approaches to the airport.

 

TNCM - Airport 14.jpgTNCM - Airport 15.jpg

 

Maho Beach

The scene at the famous Maho Beach is very well done, it is party time and the only thing missing here is the Caribbean beat music...

 

TNCM - Airport 16 LG.jpgTNCM - Airport 17.jpgTNCM - Airport 18.jpg

 

...   The extensive network of hotels on either side of Maho Beach are very well done from a realism of the area point of view.

 

TNCM - Airport 19.jpgTNCM - Airport 20.jpgTNCM - Airport 21.jpgTNCM - Airport 22.jpg

 

There is a huge amount of detail present, but also a few missing textures or unfinished areas like at the back of a few of the hotels.

 

TNCM - Airport 23.jpgTNCM - Airport 24.jpg

 

But you are certainly not lacking here for the island's tourism infrastructure and general facilities, and the vegetation is also very extensive.

 

TFFG - Grand Case-Espérance Airport

You are expecting another large airport facility for the French support of their territory, but Grand it is not, if not in that sense of the word.

 

L'Espérance Airport
Grand Case Airport

Aérodrome de Grand-Case Espérance

IATA: SFG - ICAO: TFFG

 

TFFG - Overview 1.jpgTFFG - Overview 2.jpg

 

12/30 1,200m (3,937ft) Asphalt

Elevation AMSL 20ft / 6m

 

The single 12/30 runway is situated in a valley but is opened ended at both approaches for a exciting arrival, but the runway is short and even ATR turbo-props have to reverse up to get the run required to takeoff. Incoming aircraft usually approach TFFG on short final for runway 12 over the bay of Grand-Case, with a corresponding view. When wind direction changes, which is common, incoming aircraft then change the approach to the island on short final for runway 30, in the opposite direction.

 

TFFG - Overview 3 LG.jpg

 

TNCM is actually not that far away to the south, you just take the coastal long way around to the French airport.

 

There is a nice if small ramp area and a larger GA area to the east . The airport is known for quick transfers from the larger turbo-props to the smaller GA aircraft for inter-island transfers, hence the layout.

 

TFFG - Overview 4.jpgTFFG - Overview 5.jpgTFFG - Overview 6.jpgTFFG - Overview 7.jpg

 

Small terminal is well done with a combined field control tower and Fire Station with the usual three fire engines per runway criteria. 

 

TFFG - Overview 8.jpgTFFG - Overview 9.jpg

 

Detailing as as usual very good, with a lot of static aircraft (not much parking space though) and vehicles and excellent island/airport signage. The biggest issue here though is the runway is unusable?

 

The actual runway surface (textures are like TNCM in being very good) but the surface has been set as a X-Plane "grass runway" setting and not tarmac. So when you land the aircraft it gets bogged suddenly down and it is very difficult to taxi or turn around until you get back on to the ramps harder areas? Takeoff is full power and hold on.. not doubt the issue will be fixed in an update, but currently it ruins the use of a great scenery.

 

Reefs and Coastal areas

The one area that Flight Simulator did very well in was the presentation of shallow waters, mostly in tropical and coral regions of the world. X-Plane has sort of done the same thing, but it's water system was not very good at depicting or recreating such environments, so mostly it was a confined area with big differences between the two areas with a) the shallow water in place, and b ) the hard edge where they joined up.

 

Now these shallow tropical water environments are coming into X-Plane, and there was a few nice ones with the French Polynesia scenery, but recently it was Butaru's TFFJ - Saint Barthélemy Airport by Nimbus Simulation Studios  that finally lead the way. FlyTampa with their new FlyCorfu XP scenery that was pretty impressive as well...

 

But the depiction here of such shallow water and coral scenery is one of the best and even the highlight of the scenery. So I took the Carenado Caravan for a spin around the island to have a look.

 

TNCM - Coastal 1.jpgTNCM - Coastal 2.jpgTNCM - Coastal 3.jpgTNCM - Coastal 4.jpg

 

It is really spectacular flying, and in the right atmospheric lighting conditions also very realistic. The area is very large as well which includes both the St. Maarten Island and the full area of Anguilla, south to Saba and far, far more.

 

TNCM - Coastal 5.jpgTNCM - Coastal 6.jpg

 

TNCM - Coastal 7 LG.jpg

 

There are highly-decorated cruise ships (they can also be used as a pointer to an airport runway!) but four of the same ship in one cove is a bit unrealistic? Another note that a few wakes on boats that don't exist are quite noticeable, sometimes this effect can work or work against the scenery?

 

TNCM - Coastal 10.jpgTNCM - Coastal 9.jpg

 

Detail is excellent as the shallows pass under you, the only thing missing is the swimming sharks...

 

TNCM - Coastal 8.jpgTNCM - Coastal 16.jpg

 

...  if you are willing to explore the outer coral banks then the rewards are simply outstanding.

 

TNCM - Coastal 11.jpg

 

TNCM - Coastal 12.jpgTNCM - Coastal 13.jpgTNCM - Coastal 14.jpgTNCM - Coastal 15.jpg

 

If you venture too far you do also come across the hard line of the sceneries boundary? And so more gradual transition would have made the impact more real....  but overall this is X-Plane flying par excellence!

 

TNCM - Coastal 17 LG.jpg

 

Nighlighting

This is an extensive scenery, so the lighting does have a fair area to cover.

 

TNCM - Night 1.jpgTNCM - Night 2.jpg

 

And overall here the lighting is very, very good, but that comes with a penalty. This scenery is quite possibly the largest scenery I have ever loaded into X-Plane, and it has some strange effects on to my Graphic Card's functionality (8GB). One is I get black areas and the shadow effects can sometimes go black, black instead of shaded greys, and it has a very weird effect on my WT3 aircraft view as well.

 

But the strangest effect is on framerate...  with the noted settings I have been getting mostly 50fr-60fr over the scenery (left image) and my framerate is noted in the top left corner as a respectable 57 frames...

 

TNCM - Night 3.jpgTNCM - Night 4.jpg

 

...   but the same viewpoint (abover right) in the night environment it is crushed down to 20 frames and mostly stays in the 16fr-18fr zone? Why is that so?

 

and move the camera viewpoint and the lighting disappears completely?

 

TNCM - Night 5.jpgTNCM - Night 6.jpg

 

So there is a basic issue here, or is it just too big a scenery for my computer to actually compute? if so then why does it work fine in the daylight?

 

Lighting is however very good, especially around the Airport and Terminal area, but it is quite inconsistent everywhere else.

 

TNCM - Night 7.jpgTNCM - Night 8.jpgTNCM - Night 9.jpgTNCM - Night 10.jpg

 

The highlight to the night scenery are the hotels on either side of the Maho Beach approach, as a lot of work has been done here and it shows, it is very good on the RWY 10 approach at night.

 

TNCM - Night 13.jpgTNCM - Night 14.jpg

 

But move away from the TNCM airport and some areas are well lit, but other areas in the same context are not?

 

TNCM - Night 11.jpgTNCM - Night 12.jpg

 

so it is all a bit inconsistent.

 

Over at TFFG Grand Case it is more of the inconsistency aspect than the other way around. The runway has no centreline lighting (neither does TNCM, but the real airport doesn't have any centreline lighting either)

 

TNCM - Night 15.jpgTNCM - Night 16.jpg

 

The harder point is that the lighting here at TFFG is quite small and even finding the non-lit taxiway from the runway to the ramp is a bit of an ordeal, it is arrowed here, but good luck in finding it. There are a few spots lit on the ramp and a nice lit carpark, but mostly this is not a place to fly in to or out of at night, the GA parking apron is very dark as well.

 

TNCM - Night 17.jpgTNCM - Night 18.jpg

 

But with the right atmospheric conditions (okay X-Plane effects) it is a great place to fly into is this Sint Maarten...

 

TNCM - Night 20 LG.jpg

 

Summary

Great iconic world airports are always welcome into any simulator, and the TNCM - Princess Juliana International Airport at Sint Maarten is right at the top of the list. There has been a few good, Sint Maarten sceneries for X-Plane, but this is the first real custom one created for the simulator on a larger scale.

 

As scenery goes it is very good, and even nudging into the excellent category, as there has been a huge amount of work and certainly a lot of effort put in to pleasing the requirements of what we the X-Plane users would expect from such a iconic scenery. In that context it does deliver and deliver very well.

 

My gut feeling is that scenery development of this size and scale is now really a team effort more than the single developer in wanting to deliver quality scenery, it overall feels a bit overwhelmed and consistency is brilliant in many areas but lacking in others. This is where team experience kicks in as one developer is excellent in some areas, then other team developers are good in other areas, as this is a first scenery release there is that factor to add in as well. What is missing here is that last bit of refinement, the standing back and crossing the t's and dotting the i's. I have no doubt the developer will cover the small list of issues and quickly, but in reality I would have liked more of the AutoGate, GroundTraffic, ATC routes and certainly the traffic features working far above the lovely but really unimportant flashy features of say inside the terminal building, and the scenery needs a bit of editing here and there.

 

More of a worry is the sheer size of this scenery (13.5gb)? There seems to be a refinement missing to create efficient textures and ortho images, already the 4K textures have been downsized to 2K to counter that huge size, but the night images crushing of framerates seems to suggest that there is also something more required to make this scenery a more refined and efficient scenery for the simulator to absorb, this is also reflected on the computer requirements in order to run the scenery as well.  Remember the developer is going to add in even more to this already huge scenery size in part 2 of the package, I see my computer giving up at just the thought of that, and if I can't run that sort of size and requirements then certainly a huge base of users won't be able to either.

 

The size and scope of this scenery is simply huge, and with the just released FlyCorfu XP by FlyTampa you feel X-Plane is now moving into a new era of "mega" sceneries. Overall this is very good scenery, and those excellent outer reef and shallow water conditions are flying heaven and there is plenty to explore here as well. And of course there is that iconic Maho Beach approach! you so you will just have to recreate that iconic image won't you and fully test your flying skills to the limit, and it is well worth the effort when you do so.

 

______________________________________________________________________

 

X-Plane Store logo sm.jpg

 

Yes! the TNCM - Princess of the Caribbean by AWD scenery is Available now from the X-Plane.Org Store here :

 

TNCM - Princess of the Caribbean - Part 1- SXM

 

Price Is US$32.95

 

Features:

  • Scenery created by use of on-site photography references
  •  Area of coverage: Sint Maarten island (Princess Juliana and Grand Case airports) and the island of Anguilla (only photoscenery)
  • Custom Mesh: Handcrafted mesh to match runway slopes as per the AIP and terrain modifications to give the most realism possible to the scenery 
  • Satellite Photo: 50cm/px resolution licensed from Airbus
  • Custom Grount textures: over 10px/cm nearby the airport surroundings
  • HD Buildings: The Famous Maho Beach rendered with HD textures and PBR shading effects for reflections on water and metallic surfaces
  • Terminal Interiors
  • 3d People and Trees
  • Custom Night Lighting: realistic apron lighting matching colors and light intensity of the real airport
  • Custom Autogen: the whole Island is covered in scenery
  • Custom Static Aircraft
  • Multiple detail configurations available planned for detail or speed

 

 

 

 

Requirements

X-Plane 11+

Windows, Mac or Linux
4Gb VRAM Video Card Minimum - 8Gb+ VRAM recommended
Please read the manual about rendering options before you start.
Download Size: 5.5 Gb  (please do not get if you have an unstable internet connection. you have been warned!)
A minimum 16gb of RAM is required for efficient running of this scenery, and even then you are lineball.
 
Installation
Download scenery file size is 5.5Gb. With the full installation installed package is 14.71gb in your custom scenery folder is as follows:
 
  • AWD TNCM - 2 - Apt (14.71gb)
  • AWD TNCM - 3 - Mesh (4.4mb)

 

If you have installed in your custom folder TFFJ - Saint Barthélemy Airport by Nimbus Simulation Studios then be aware of the mesh conflicts between the two packages, the AWD sceneries need to be lower in your .ini list than the TFFJ Nimbus scenery or the AWD scenery will cancel out TFFJ? Otherwise they work very well together.

 

WT3 ground routes are here : GroundRoutes_TNCM V1.0

But they are certainly not adjusted or created for this scenery, they work and that is about that...

 

Documents

A single two page pdf manual is included but no charts

 

These TNCM charts are worth downloading : TNCM uvairlines

 

______________________________________________________________________

 

Scenery Review by Stephen Dutton

14th April 2018

Copyright©2018 : X-Plane Reviews

 

(Disclaimer. All images and text in this review are the work and property of X-PlaneReviews, no sharing or copy of the content is allowed without consent from the author as per copyright conditions)

 

Review System Specifications:

Computer System: Windows  - Intel Core i7 6700K CPU 4.00GHz / 64bit - 16 Gb single 1067 Mhz DDR4 2133 - ASUS GeForce GTX 1080 8Gb - Samsung Evo 512gb SSD 

Software:   - Windows 10 - X-Plane 11.10

Addons: Saitek x56 Rhino Pro system Joystick and Throttle : Sound - Bose  Soundlink Mini

Plugins: Environment Engine by xEnviro US$69.90 : XPRealistic Pro v1.0.9  effects US$19.95 : WorldTraffic 3.0 Plugin - US$29.95

Scenery or Aircraft

- C208B Grand Caravan HD Series XP11 by Carenado (X-Plane.OrgStore) US$34.95

- Boeing 747-400 by Laminar Research (default Aircraft X-Plane11)

 

Logo Header X-PlaneReviews 200px.jpg

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×